Maggie Skhosana Assumes Role as Mpumalanga Director General
March 4, 2025
South Africa’s B20 and G20 Leadership
March 4, 2025
A bold worker-ownership experiment in South Africa’s coal mining sector is on the verge of failure as Arnot Opco Coal Mine in Mpumalanga struggles to secure funding and resume full operations.
The mine, acquired by retrenched workers after Exxaro ceased operations in 2015, symbolized hope for more than 1,000 former employees. However, financial troubles, legal battles, and the global transition away from coal now threaten its survival.
Funding Crisis and Legal Battle
During an oversight visit by the Portfolio Committee on Mineral and Petroleum Resources, Arnot Opco’s management revealed that the mine is under business rescue and locked in a court battle with Wescoal, its former shareholder.
“Wescoal committed R150 million in funding but failed to provide it,” said Arnot Opco’s management. “Combined with the impact of Covid-19, this has left us unable to fully operate the mine.”
The Rise and Fall of Worker Ownership
Arnot Opco’s story began in 2015, when Exxaro retrenched 1,500 workers after losing its Eskom coal supply contract. Determined to take control of their futures, eight former employees formed Innovators Resources and took over the mine, establishing a trust benefiting 1,029 retrenched workers.
They partnered with Wescoal to secure funding and expertise. However, the failure of Wescoal’s financial commitment, coupled with economic fallout from the pandemic, prevented the mine from operating at full capacity.
A Mine Without Mining
Today, no mining takes place at Arnot Opco. Instead, the company buys coal from third parties, washes it, and sells it—a stark contrast to the dream of a thriving, worker-run mine.
The coal industry’s financial struggles have made securing capital nearly impossible, as lenders shift away from fossil fuel projects.
“It is very difficult to raise funding right now,” said the company’s management. “Lenders are hesitant to support distressed businesses, especially in the coal sector, due to the global transition to clean energy.”
Government’s Concerns and Community Impact
Committee Chairperson Mikateko Mahlaule emphasized the importance of the worker-ownership model but stressed the need for accountability.
“We want this mine to succeed. This is a model we have not seen before, and it must work. But companies must also benefit communities, not just extract and leave,” he said.
The committee’s visit also exposed broader concerns in Mpumalanga’s coal sector:
- Failure to uphold Social Labour Plans (SLPs): Community leaders accused mining companies of securing licenses with promises of development but failing to deliver once profitable.
- Mass retrenchments: Labour unions claimed companies are replacing permanent workers with contract employees, undermining job security and worker rights.
Uncertain Future for Arnot Opco
With no active mining and thousands of jobs at stake, Arnot Opco’s future hangs in the balance. Plans to appoint contractors and restart operations are underway, but without urgent funding, the worker-owned experiment may soon collapse.
